• Home
  • True Crime
  • Thrillers
  • Mystery
  • Sci-Fi/Fantasy
  • Horror
  • Business
  • History
  • Reader Favorites
    • Award Winners
    • Bestsellers
    • Box Sets
    • Coming Soon
    • New Releases

WildBlue Press

Great Reads from Exceptional Authors

Great Reads from
Exceptional Authors

  • Subscribe
  • Interested Authors
  • Blog
    • In the Media
  • About Us
    • Catalog
    • Privacy Policy
  • Partners
    • ImaginePublicity
    • MacGregor Literary
    • The House Of Mystery with Al Warren
  • Contact Us

Author Caitlin Rother; Taking a Look at the Death Penalty, Nationally and in California

Author Caitlin Rother

When Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order to extend the moratorium on executions in California in March, the lead detective and the victims’ families in the Hawks case were all very upset.

After sitting through three trials in this case, two of which resulted in death sentences for defendants who killed their family members, they have been waiting a decade to see these murderers receive the ultimate punishment. But they are likely going to have to wait quite a while longer.

Even though voters have backed the death penalty in state referendums as recently as 2016, California has had a moratorium on executions since 2006. This is due to court challenges to the previous three-drug lethal injection protocol, in which one of the drugs was said to cause extreme pain, a violation of the U.S. Constitution protection against “cruel and unusual punishment.”

Newsom issued his reprieve just as the public approval process for a new protocol was about to end, saying that he couldn’t, in good conscience, carry out a capital punishment that killed even a small percentage of innocent people. He also dismantled the brand new, never-used death chamber that his Republican predecessor, Arnold Schwarzenegger, built for $853,000.

Citing a National Academy of Sciences study, Newsom said that one in every twenty-five people executed in the United States, primarily men, is estimated to be innocent. He believed this finding gave him a moral imperative to act.

“If that’s the case, that means if we move forward executing 737 people in California, we will have executed roughly 30 people that are innocent,” he said. “I don’t know about you. I can’t sign my name to that. I can’t be party to that. I won’t be able to sleep at night.”

I’m not taking a position either way on the death penalty, because I believe it’s best for an investigative journalist and author like me to stay neutral on such topics. But I do want to state for the record that when I was still working as a daily newspaper reporter, covering jails and prisons for The San Diego Union-Tribune, I thought it was important to personally witness an execution.

I had to go to San Quentin twice for the same execution, returning some months later after the inmate received a last-minute stay. I got almost no sleep the night before my first trip, and I hardly slept the night I finally watched Tommy Thompson be executed in 1998. I stayed up writing my news story until 3 or 4 A.M., then got up early to interview the folks in the seats facing Thompson to find out what they witnessed. Standing off the side with the other media, I had a different, limited perspective.

Thompson went to his grave avowing his innocence. Years after he and his codefendant were tried and convicted, his codefendant said that he witnessed Thompson having what appeared to be consensual sex with a woman who was later found murdered. The special circumstance that made Thompson eligible for the death penalty was rape, and without that act to provide the motive for the murder of the young female victim, it’s possible that Thompson was telling the truth and only helped his buddy bury the woman’s body. Two jurors came forward once they learned this, and said they would have voted otherwise at trial if they’d known this before.

Given these facts, it was disturbing to watch him die, especially as he repeatedly pulled himself up off the table to mouth the words “I love you” to a woman in the stands, on the other side of the glass.

Now that I’m releasing an updated edition of my book, DEAD RECKONING, which features two convicted killers who are sitting on death row at San Quentin, I thought this was a good opportunity to explore national trends surrounding the issue of capital punishment.

On a state-by-state basis, the primary trend has been a downturn in the number of states supporting the death penalty. Within the past 15 years, eight states have abandoned the practice through legislation or the courts.

There also has been a decline in the number of actual executions, which are highly geographically concentrated in just five states: Texas leads the pack, with half of them occurring there. The others are Tennessee, Alabama, Florida and Georgia. Overall, the majority of the cases leading to executions are tried in only 2 percent of the nation’s counties.   

California has the nation’s largest death row population—twice the size of Florida’s, which has the next largest. California has 710 men awaiting execution at San Quentin, and 24 women, who are housed at the California Central Women’s Facility in Chowchilla. This is the same prison where Skylar Deleon’s ex-wife and codefendant, Jennifer Henderson, was sentenced to serve a term of life without the possibility of parole.

Of the 135 death row inmates who have died in California since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976, only 13 of them have been executed; all the others died of suicide or natural causes.

Before Newsom made his move in March, six other governors had urged his predecessor, Jerry Brown, to roll back the death sentences of the 740 inmates living on death row at that time. But Brown refused. 

Newsom clearly felt otherwise. Today, California is one of four states whose governors have issued moratoriums (the others are Pennsylvania, Colorado and Oregon), and one of 11 states that have the death penalty on the books, but haven’t used it in more than a decade.

Nationally, twenty-five states still have the death penalty, most of which are in the Midwest and South. The twenty-one that don’t have the death penalty are primarily in the Northwest, starting in North Dakota and moving east, (with the exception of New Mexico and Washington). The other four have moratoriums.

But until or unless the system is formally changed in California, prosecutors will continue to charge and try defendants in death penalty cases. “We’ve all arrived at the same conclusion,” San Mateo County prosecutor Steve Wagstaffe, the former president of the California District Attorneys Association, said in July. “We need to continue to do our jobs. The law is still on the books.”

That could change in light of Newsom’s reprieve. In July, the California Supreme Court weighed whether to “freeze” all death penalty trials. The argument was that juries couldn’t be expected to decide whether to recommend a death sentence if executions weren’t actually going to occur. That decision was pending when I wrote this blog.

Although for many the death penalty is a moral issue, it is also a financial and very political one. While some view it as a useful deterrent, others see it as part of a racially biased system that kills a disproportionate percentage of people of color, some of whom have been found to be innocent before and after they’ve been executed.

U.S. Attorney General William Barr recently took this issue in a new direction by ordering the federal government to restart executions after a new protocol is adopted, starting with five inmates already on federal death row. That may be more complicated than it might seem, because the protocol issue is what triggered California’s moratorium in 2006.

Sending someone to death row is quite a costly endeavor for taxpayers, because death penalty trials are often delayed and then are longer once they start. They involve more experts and witnesses, the defendant gets two attorneys vs. one (usually paid with tax dollars), and the trials have two phases vs. one.

On average, a death penalty trial generally costs twice as much as a murder trial without the special circumstance allegations that make the defendant eligible for the death penalty, the latter of which typically result in sentences of life without parole, known as LWOP. Similarly, the appeals for death cases are also longer and more involved, all because a person’s life hangs in the balance.

The subject of Caitlin’s book DEAD RECKONING, Skylar Deleon, whom is currently housed on death row. Photo by CDCR

Those costs escalate when a system like California’s is broken, because prosecutors continue to charge and try defendants under the current system, even though the convicts will just sit in prison anyway—in single cells, with more security, and less yard time, making it more expensive to house them.

Even the Manson Family members, who were originally sent to death row, had their sentences commuted to life (with the possibility of parole) when the death penalty was found to be unconstitutional in 1972.

Charles Manson, viewed as the most notorious mass murderer of the 20th century, was technically eligible for parole but he stopped attending his own parole hearings, because he knew he’d never be released. He died at 83 of cancer and other natural causes in 2018. (For more information on that topic, you can read my book, HUNTING CHARLES MANSON, co-authored with Lis Wiehl.)

The information and statistics used in this blog came from the Pew Research Center, the American Bar Association, the National Death Penalty Archive, Phys.org, the Death Penalty Information Center, and various mainstream news stories.

You can order the book here: Amazon: wbp.bz/deadreckoninga

You can find out more about the book here: wbp.bz/deadreckoning

And you can learn more about me by visiting my website, https://caitlinrother.com. You can also find me on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Filed Under: Blog, Caitlin Rother, DEAD RECKONING, True Crime Tagged With: Caitlin Rother, California, DEAD RECKONING, death penalty, Homicide, jail, Murder, New York Times Bestseller, New York Times bestselling, prison, second edition, Skylar Deleon, transgender
September 12, 2019 By Caitlin Rother Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

DEAD RECKONING by Caitlin Rother

Buy DEAD RECKONING now:

Star Rating

Amazon Kindle eBookBarnes & Noble Nook eBookKobo eBook  eBook
Amazon Trade Paperback  Paperback

INTERNATIONAL KINDLE EBOOKS
USA  UK  Canada  Australia  Germany  France  Spain  Japan  Italy  Brazil  India  Mexico

More From Author Caitlin Rother

Audiobook Offer

Free Audiobooks!

It's always a good day for free audiobooks! That's right! Free audiobooks! Just a gift from us to you, our readers.   Browse by genre and select the cover to get more information and your free copy! Non-Fiction True Crime Business … [Read More...]

Holiday 2020 Audiobook Giveaway, get free audiobooks

Holiday 2020 Audiobook Giveaway

We know how hard 2020 has been. To help you end the year on a better note, we wanted to give you the gift of free audiobooks! Hence, the Holiday 2020 Audiobook Giveaway! You're probably thinking of gifts for others right now, like we always do during … [Read More...]

Stranger Than Fiction: 10 Unbelievable True Crime Stories

Big Bird finding a dead woman in his house; a cannibal police officer; a horse suspected of murder; a mysterious crate with horrifying contents; a teenager who murdered his baby sister; one criminal's shocking motive for killing three people; a lady … [Read More...]

Anne K. Howard

We Asked Our Female Authors “Why Do Women Love True Crime?”

In response to an article recently published by The New York Times titled "Why Do Women Love True Crime?", we asked some of our many talented female authors the same question. Caitlin Rother, New York Times Bestselling Author Of DEAD RECKONING … [Read More...]

Author Caitlin Rother; Taking a Look at the Death Penalty, Nationally and in California

When Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order to extend the moratorium on executions in California in March, the lead detective and the victims’ families in the Hawks case were all very upset. After sitting through three trials in this case, two of … [Read More...]

Rother Looks Back on the Career-long Coverage of a Murder Case

As a professional journalist for the past 32 years, I’ve published thousands of news and feature articles for newspapers and magazines. I’ve also written and coauthored 13 books since 2005, penned countless blog posts, and I’m working on two new … [Read More...]

DEAD RECKONING by New York Times Bestselling Author Caitlin Rother

Tom and Jackie Hawks loved their life in retirement, sailing on their yacht, the Well Deserved. But when the birth of a new grandson called them back to Arizona, they put the boat up for sale. Skylar Deleon and his pregnant wife Jennifer showed … [Read More...]

New York Times Bestselling Author Caitlin Rother Releases Updated Edition of DEAD RECKONING, Packed With New Details

I’m thrilled to announce that I’m working with WildBlue Press once again, this time to release a newly revised and updated version of my book, DEAD RECKONING, one of my most popular books. So much has changed since the book was originally … [Read More...]

More True Crime From WildBlue Press

THE DECISION TO KILL Leslie Ghiglieri

THE DECISION TO KILL

… [Read More...]

TED BUNDY The Yearly Journal Volume One

TED BUNDY The Yearly Journal Volume One

… [Read More...]

THE LAST JEWISH GANGSTER Volume One The Early Years David Larson Kindle Cover

THE LAST JEWISH GANGSTER

… [Read More...]

ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER William Craig

ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER

… [Read More...]

CARMINE AND THE 13th AVENUE BOYS Craig McGuire

CARMINE AND THE 13th AVENUE BOYS

… [Read More...]

VAMPIRES, GATORS, AND WACKOS Frank Stanfield

VAMPIRES, GATORS, AND WACKOS: True Crime Stories From A Florida Newspaperman

… [Read More...]

THE CURSE OF THE TURTLE Suzanne Buchanan

Suzanne Buchanan Exposes The Sinister Truth Behind “The Backpacker Murders” and Thailand’s Mafia In New True Crime THE CURSE OF THE TURTLE

… [Read More...]

DEADLY ASSOCIATES Kindle Cover

DEADLY ASSOCIATES: A True Story Of Murder, Survival, and Bringing Down the Chicago Mob

… [Read More...]

Genres, Types

New Releases
Featured Books
Coming Soon
Award Winners

Business
History
Horror
Mysteries
Romance
Sci-Fi/Fantasy
Thrillers
True Crime

eBooks
Paperbacks
Audio Books
Box Sets

Available

True Crime
• Ted Bundy
• The Last Jewish Gangster
• Carmine And The 13Th Avenue Boys
• Vampires, Gators, And Wackos
• The Curse Of The Turtle
• Deadly Associates
• Jane Doe 9
• Watch Me Die
• Mystery At The Blue Sea Cottage
• The Wheels Of Justice
• 16 Minutes
• Terror Town, Usa
• Raging On
• Grilling Dahmer
• The 'Peyton Place' Murder
• Cold Blooded
• Faith Based Fraud
• The Real Mr. Big
• The Son Of Seven Mothers
• 'The Son Of Sam' And Me
• Serial Killers
• Satin Pumps
• Out Of The Mouths Of Serial Killers
• True Crime Chronicles Volume Two
• The World Encyclopedia Of Serial Killers Volume Three
• The Enigma Of Ted Bundy
• True Crime Chronicles Volume One
• Killing Women
• From The Mob To The Movies
• The World Encyclopedia Of Serial Killers Volume Two
• To Kill Or Be Killed
• No Angels
• Monster
• Under A Full Moon
• 'Til Death Do Us ...'
• The World Encyclopedia Of Serial Killers
• First Degree Rage
• The 'Supreme Gentleman' Killer
• Beast Of New Castle
• The Garden State Parkway Murders
• How Now, Butterfly?
• The Encyclopedia Of The Ted Bundy Murders
• Survival
• Missing ... And Presumed Dead
• Wrong Numbers
• Tantamount
• Playing Dead
• Mothers And Murderers
• Dead Reckoning
• Underworld
• Gabacho
• The Gangster's Cousin
• Race To Justice
• Ted Bundy's Murderous Mysteries
• Travesty Of Justice
• Railroaded
• You Have A Very Soft Voice, Susan
• A Family Business
• Pathological
• Wrecking Crew
• The Last Man Standing
• My Son, The Killer
• Inconvenience Gone
• Toxic Rage
• The Killing Game
• Shots In The Dark
• The Case Of The Golden State Killer
• His Garden
• The Crate
• Burned
• The Case Of The Zodiac Killer
• A Murder In My Hometown
• Bullied To Death
• The Beast I Loved
• Summary Execution
• The Shawcross Letters
• Better Off Dead
• Sidetracked
• My Brother's Keeper
• Targeted
• Held Hostage
• Room 1203
• A Special Kind Of Evil
• Brooklyn's Most Wanted
• Outlaw Los Angeles
• Unsolved No More
• She Is Evil
• The Rise And Fall Of A Casino Mobster
• Outlaw Southwest
• A Clockwork Murder
• Raw Deal
• The Bundy Secrets
• Betrayal In Blue
• The Politics Of Murder
• Murderers Row
• Rough Trade
• Daddy's Little Secret
• Murder In The Family
• Failure Of Justice
• Ice And Bone
• Smooth Talker
• The Trail Of Ted Bundy
• A Taste For Murder
• Sketchcop
• Body Of Proof
• Kentucky Bloodbath
• No Stone Unturned
• Repeat Offender
• Dixie's Last Stand
• Vampire
• Man Overboard
• Bogeyman
• Murderers Row Volume Two
Thriller
• Blood Red Ivory
• No One Will Hear Your Screams
• The Screaming Room
• Bone Thief
• Crux
• Sword Of The Caliphate
• Last Son Of The War God
• Leviathan
• The Strait
• Enemy Of The People
• Cain
• Dark Visions
• Hunter
• The Reckoning
• Hard Dog To Kill
• 16 Souls
• Borderland
• Paper Wings
• Lockout
• Pitfall
Mystery
• The Humanzee Experiments
• The Killing Machine
• Murder At Mardi Gras
• The Right Thing
• Raven's Ridge
• Raptor's Ridge
• Napa Noir
• Melia Ridge
• Emerald Ridge
• Created
• Crevice
• Headlock
• Identity Crisis
• The Obituary
• Naked Addiction
• The Deadline
Horror
• Four
• Acadia Event
• The Red Son
• Highwayman
• The Equinox
• The Pure And The Hated
• Savage Highway
Sci-Fi/Fantasy
• Tribulations
• Happenstance
• Destruction Of Justice
• Blunt Force Magic
Business
• Leaderology
• The Age Of Pluralism
• Bamboo Strong
• Corporate Superpower
• Wordpress Websites For Business
• Productivity Tools For Business
Cookbook
• Frank Cullotta's Greatest (Kitchen) Hits
History
• Legion Rising
• The Korean Crisis
• Tempest Tost
• Saving Sandoval
• Killing Rasputin
Politics
• The (Redacted) Mueller Report
Romance
• When Fall Fades

New Releases

TED BUNDY The Yearly Journal Volume One

TED BUNDY The Yearly Journal Volume One

Due to Sullivan’s extensive writing about Ted Bundy (which has produced six books), he’s become a sort of magnet over the years, drawing out many people who were part of the Bundy story, but have otherwise kept a low profile over the decades; and … [More...]

THE LAST JEWISH GANGSTER Volume One The Early Years David Larson Kindle Cover

THE LAST JEWISH GANGSTER

Volume One The Early Years In 1944 Brooklyn, newborn Michael J. Hardy is rejected by his mother so she can run with gangster Bugsy Siegel, Hardy’s godfather. Shirley Rook rose to the top of the criminal ranks. As the Queen of New York City … [More...]

CARMINE AND THE 13th AVENUE BOYS Craig McGuire

CARMINE AND THE 13th AVENUE BOYS

This is the true story of Carmine Imbriale – a gambler, a brawler, a bandit, a bookie, an enforcer. For two decades, Imbriale was a street-level operative in one of the most violent crews in the Colombo Family, and he endeared himself to some of the … [More...]

THE HUMANZEE EXPERIMENTS Terry Persun

THE HUMANZEE EXPERIMENTS: This Time Science Went Too Far

Ten must track down and stop rogue scientists behind the development of criminal technology in THE HUMANZEEE EXPERIMENTS, the next installment of The 'Ten' Mystery Series! The International Security for Technological Innovations, a federal … [More...]

Coming Soon

THE DECISION TO KILL Leslie Ghiglieri

THE DECISION TO KILL

A 1986 family tragedy propels this gripping true crime debut as a mother searches for answers in the shocking murder of her husband—and conviction of her son. For years, Cherie struggles to overcome the consuming grief she suffers from the loss of … [More...]

ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER William Craig

ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER

It was a dreary winter afternoon in Ayer, Massachusetts, a quintessential New England town, the type which is romanticized in Robert Frost's poems. But on January 30, 1979, a woman’s scream was heard piercing the northeast tempest wind. In an … [More...]

Recent Posts

  • THE DECISION TO KILL
  • TED BUNDY The Yearly Journal Volume One
  • THE LAST JEWISH GANGSTER
  • ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER
  • CARMINE AND THE 13th AVENUE BOYS
  • Massive True Crime Sale. Today Only!
  • THE HUMANZEE EXPERIMENTS: This Time Science Went Too Far

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

eZine SignupJoin our email list and be the first to get hot deals, new releases and...
* Author updates
* Free eBooks
* Free audio books
* Enlightening and entertaining posts
* Advance notice of book deals, special offers

Follow Us

Blog Tag Cloud

best true crime books Bogeyman Bradley Nickell Brian Whitney Burl Barer Caitlin Rother Cold Case Crime Fiction Crime thriller Detective Detectives Facebook True Crime John Ferak Kevin Sullivan Las Vegas memoir Murder murder book murder mystery Mysteries Mystery mystery thriller Non-Fiction Ron Franscell Serial Killer serial killer books Serial Killers Steve Jackson Suspense suspense thriller Ted Bundy Thriller Thriller Books Thrillers True-crime truecrime True Crime True Crime Authors true crime book true crime books True Crime Original true crimes true crime stories True Murder WildBlue Press

Privacy Policy

As Seen On:

Our Authors Have Been Seen On...

Interested Authors Click Here
See Our Entire Catalog
SSL Secure Connection

Copyright © 2022 WildBlue Press. All rights reserved.
Website design by Denver Local SEO Marketing Company
Author Caitlin Rother; Taking a Look at the Death Penalty, Nationally and in California