• Subscribe
  • Submit
    • True Crime Submissions
  • Blog
    • All Posts
    • Media Appearance Archives
    • WildBlue Press Author Bios
    • Crime Fiction Books
    • Fantasy Books
    • History Books
    • Horror Books
    • Mystery Books
    • Romance Books
    • Science Fiction Books
    • Thriller Books
    • True Crime Books
  • About WBP
    • Catalog
    • Our Story
    • Privacy Policy
    • Partner Links
      • ACX (blog)
      • BookBub (author resources)
      • bookshop.org
      • The House Of Mystery with Al Warren
      • ImaginePublicity
      • MacGregor Literary
      • Open Road Media
      • True Crime Uncensored with Burl Barer and Mark Boyer
      • Tantor Media
      • That’s Criminal Podcast with John Stamp
    • Resources for Authors
  • Contact
    • Get in Touch
    • Acquisitions Team Sign-Up
    • Street Team Sign-Up

WildBlue Press True Crime Website

Great Reads from Exceptional Authors

Great Reads from
Exceptional Authors

  • True Crime
  • Thrillers
  • Science Fiction
  • Mystery
  • Horror
  • Fantasy
  • History
  • Business

Author Tiddy Smith Discusses Police Misconduct in Durham

Get DEATH BY TALONS
  eBook
Amazon Kindle eBook Barnes & Noble Nook eBook Kobo eBook Apple eBook Google Play eBook
  Paperback
Barnes & Noble Trade Paperback Amazon Trade Paperback
  Audio Book
Audible Audio Book

The city of Durham in North Carolina had a serious problem with police misconduct at the beginning of the 21st century. The most famous example was the so-called “Duke Lacrosse” case, which gained worldwide attention. In this case, a young Black woman accused three Duke University students, lacrosse players, of having committed a brutal, racially-motivated gang rape upon her.

The woman’s story about what had happened on the night in question radically changed at least five times in the course of the investigation. Nevertheless, the District Attorney, Mike Nifong, pursued the rape charges against the three white students. Nifong gave dozens of interviews to the media, in which he painted a picture of the young men as racists and perpetrators of a hate crime. He reassured the city of Durham that they would be swiftly brought to justice.

Nifong already knew, however, that a rape kit had been used to test the accuser and it proved that none of the student's DNA was in her anal or pubic regions. The results of these tests were hidden from the students’ lawyers.

Eventually, the truth came out. Nifong was disbarred and found guilty of obstruction of justice. For his outrageous abuse of power, he spent a single day in prison.

Nifong had taken the helm from a man called Jim Hardin, who had resigned from the position of District Attorney in 2005. And in truth, Nifong had inherited a corrupt office. Hardin was the District Attorney who had pushed forward with murder charges in an even more famous case: the murder case against Michael Peterson.

Michael Peterson had been charged with the murder of his wife in 2001 and was found guilty at the end of a lengthy trial in 2003. The case garnered international attention after the release of the Staircase docuseries in 2004 and a related dramatized miniseries in 2022. In Michael’s case, just like the Duke Lacrosse case, there is troubling evidence of both police and prosecutorial misconduct. The two cases stand in parallel because in both cases exculpatory evidence was hidden from the defense.

Importantly, the prosecution had argued that Michael had killed his wife with a fireplace blow poke which had “mysteriously vanished” from the house in the wake of Kathleen’s death. On one of the final days of Michael’s trial, his son Clayton discovered the blow poke leaning against a wall in the basement of the house. The poker was, by now, covered in cobwebs, but it was not dented or bent and it had no blood on it. It was presented at the end of the trial with a grand flourish, to the annoyance of the District Attorney. The discovery of the blow poke made no difference to the outcome, however. Michael was found guilty of Kathleen’s murder and would spend eight years in prison.

But as would become apparent in the years following Michael’s trial, the police forensic team had already found the blow poke, photographed it, and set it back in the basement during a search of the property in 2002. Despite the fact that the State’s case hinged on the mysteriously missing blow poke, no one mentioned the fact that it had already been found, photographed, and disregarded as a possible murder weapon. The evidence was, it seems, deliberately withheld from the defense.

This was not the only example of hidden evidence. In 2003, a neighbor of the Petersons, Larry Pollard, began to promote the idea that an owl may have been responsible for the trident-shaped lacerations that were found on Kathleen’s head. The theory was outrageous and most people felt that Pollard was simply clutching at straws to save his much-beloved neighbor. After all, if a bird was responsible for Kathleen’s death, there should have been feathers at the scene. But no feathers were discovered. Therefore, there was no owl.

Pollard was no idiot. He was an attorney who had previously worked as legal counsel for some of the highest-ranked officials in North Carolina. He had also worked within the Special Prosecutors Office. He knew that if his theory was correct, some evidence of an owl must have been found. So, at the end of 2003, Pollard wrote a letter to District Attorney Jim Hardin asking whether any feathers had been discovered at the crime scene. He received a short letter in reply, which stated that no feathers were found in the course of the investigation.

Because of his previous employment, Pollard had all kinds of contacts within North Carolina’s Special Investigations Division. Through these channels, he received a copy of the forensic trace evidence report. He read through the report line by line.

On page three, he read that a feather had indeed been discovered in Kathleen’s hair. He requested access to the microscopy slide on which the hair was set. With the aid of a microscope, he was able to see that this was not just one feather, but two which had become glued to Kathleen’s hair with her own dry blood.

Durham’s authorities had lied to Larry about the feather. And Durham’s authorities had lied to the defense about the blow poke. They lied about many other facts which would have serious consequences in the case against Michael Peterson. Alongside the Duke Lacrosse case, the Michael Peterson case stands as another example of bad behavior by Durham's police and prosecutors. How was such a culture of corruption allowed to thrive for so many years?

Filed Under: Blog, Tiddy Smith, True Crime Tagged With: cover-up, Crystal Magnum, Duke Lacrosse, Duke University, Durham, Evidence, Fred Rosen, Kathleen Peterson, Media, Michael Peterson, misconduct, Murder, news, North Carolina, police, prison, rape kit, sexual assault
March 8, 2023 By Tiddy Smith Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

DEATH BY TALONS

Buy DEATH BY TALONS: Did An Owl ‘Murder’ Kathleen Peterson? by Tiddy Smith now!

Amazon Kindle eBook Barnes & Noble Nook eBook Kobo eBook Apple eBook Google Play eBook  eBook
Hard Cover  Hard Cover
Barnes & Noble Trade Paperback Amazon Trade Paperback  Paperback

INTERNATIONAL KINDLE EBOOKS
USA   UK   Canada   Australia   Germany   France   Spain   Japan   Italy   Brazil   India   Mexico

GET A FREE AUDIBLE AUDIOBOOK

Get this Title for FREE at Audible with a free trialGet this Audible Title for FREE with a 30-day free trial

LISTEN TO A SAMPLE OF THE AUDIOBOOK

Hear Interviews with Tiddy Smith

Read More From Tiddy Smith

featured image for Author Interview

Tiddy Smith Discusses DEATH BY TALONS on Wicked Words | Listen to the Riveting Conversation

For those passionate about true crime who have yet to explore the enthralling realm of Wicked Words, the opportune moment has arrived! Our accomplished author, Tiddy Smith, takes center stage in the latest episode. [The owl theory] sounds stupid.” —From the show Released earlier this year, Smith’s DEATH BY TALONS unravels the mysterious death of […]

featured image with text "endorsed by Larry Pollard"

Read Larry Pollard’s Powerful Endorsement of DEATH BY TALONS by Tiddy Smith

In March 2023, Tiddy Smith’s DEATH BY TALONS hit the shelves, shedding light on Kathleen Peterson’s tragic death—and the disconcerting facts and unsettling implications about what might have been known by the police. The book ended up in the hands of none other than Larry Pollard, whose review is more than an endorsement; it’s a […]

Featured Image for DBT Gallery

Gallery | DEATH BY TALONS: Did An Owl ‘Murder’ Kathleen Peterson? by Tiddy Smith

Get DEATH BY TALONS   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book DEATH BY TALONS: Did An Owl ‘Murder’ Kathleen Peterson goes beyond the theories and speculations and uncovers the shocking conspiracy surrounding the infamous “Staircase” investigation. In this photo gallery, find the color versions of black and white images contained in the paperback and hardcover copies of the book. […]

Death By Talons Book Cover

Author Tiddy Smith Explores ‘Owl Theory’ and North Carolina’s Infamous ‘Staircase Murder’ in DEATH BY TALONS: Did An Owl ‘Murder’ Kathleen Peterson?

Get DEATH BY TALONS   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book In [DEATH BY TALONS], all the evidence is laid bare… I highly recommend this book!” —Larry Pollard It was not enough to suggest that Kathleen began to bleed outside. It was not enough to point to prior owl attacks on humans. Larry needed a smoking gun. And […]

Featured Image with owl for new author blog post

A Fatal Owl Attack Has At Least One Historical Precedent, Says Author Tiddy Smith

Get DEATH BY JTALONS The unusual death of Kathleen Peterson in her home in Durham, North Carolina has attracted a tremendous amount of media attention since it occurred in December, 2001. It was first brought to international prominence by Jean-Xavier de Lestrade’s docuseries The Staircase, released in 2004. It was later rereleased in extended form […]

Author Blog Quote "It's not science fiction any more; it's science fact."

Author Tiddy Smith On ‘Jurassic Park’ and ‘The Boys from Brazil’

In 1996, a sheep called Dolly was born. She was the first mammal in history to be cloned from an adult. For this reason, Dolly had three mothers: the one who provided the egg, the one who carried her to term, and the one who provided the DNA. It was a remarkable leap from science […]

Featured Image

Scholar and DEATH BY TALONS Author Tiddy Smith Answers “Who Is Larry Pollard?”

Get DEATH BY JTALONS Thomas Lawrence Pollard, better known as Larry Pollard, was born in Durham, North Carolina in 1948. He was the son of Julia Davis Pollard and Forrest Pollard sr. Studying law at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, he would go on to work in some of the most prestigious legal […]

Author Tiddy Smith Tells Why He Wrote About The Kathleen Peterson Case

Get DEATH BY JTALONS I have always been intrigued by claims of the strange and unusual: Things like ghosts, extraterrestrials, sea monsters and sinister conspiracies. ghosts, extraterrestrials, conspiracy, Ira Levin, Rosemary’s Baby, The Boys from Brazil For this reason, perhaps, my favourite fiction writer was always Ira Levin. I remember reading Rosemary’s Baby for the […]

More Posts from this Category

More True Crime From WildBlue Press

Lawyer beind a desk and black and white image of her with convicted man

Get WRECKING CREW   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book “Ferak chronicles the long and sordid history of the Manitowoc County Sheriff’s Department and the reason Sweaty’s license was suspended. Framing Avery was just par for the course.” —Kathleen Zellner Updated 5th Anniversary Edition Including Exclusive Interview with Steve Avery In 2016-17, while working for the USA TODAY […]

dirty white background, red and black text, and eyeglasses: book cover

Frank C. Girardot is the pit bull crime reporter other crime reporters wish they were.” —JAMES ELLROY, author of The Black Dahlia BECOMING CLARK ROCKEFELLER: Murder, Love, Deception, and the Con Man Behind It All delves into the life of a young immigrant entangled in a multi-generational murder investigation ensnaring some of the wealthiest Americans. […]

Book cover for 'Monsters on the Loose' by Richard L. Carrico

Get MONSTERS ON THE LOOSE   eBook   Paperback As an archaeologist, historian, and now murder investigator, the intellectual curiosity of Richard Carrico has no limits. Well researched and written, his new work, as with all good mysteries, takes us into unknown territories and keeps us reading well into the dark night. —GEORGE H. HARWOOD, Author and […]

front cover for MURDERERS' ROW volume four

Get MURDERERS’ ROW, VOLUME FOUR   eBook New eBook Collection Out Now! This three-in-one volume features Edgar Award-winning author Burl Barer’s works: MAN OVERBOARD, BETRAYAL IN BLUE, and A TASTE FOR MURDER. Barer, a media legend with a decades-spanning career, is a one-of-a-kind, must-read true crime master. MAN OVERBOARD: The Counterfeit Resurrection of Phil Champagne details […]

book cover

Get GRIM PARADISE   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book Get GRIM PARADISE   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book When widow Frances Lacey was murdered in July 1960 on Mackinac Island, only a few meager clues were found by police, and the case soon turned cold. But more than sixty years later, will those same clues finally solve the mystery? […]

front cover

Get ABOVE THE GROUND   eBook   Paperback In 1978, the bloody conflict in Northern Ireland, known as The Troubles, reached a boiling point. Hundreds of members of the Irish Republican Army determined to drive the hated British out of the province—killing soldiers and police, detonating bombs, while arming themselves with firearms and explosives—were arrested and incarcerated […]

book cover

Get BAD HENRY   eBook   Paperback   Audio Book Henry Louis Wallace terrorized Charlotte, North Carolina, from May 1992 to March 1994. Wallace preyed on lower economic-class Black women between 17 and 35 years old. He knew most of his victims, some through his job at Taco Bell, and gained their trust with his friendly demeanor and […]

front cover for coal country killing

VISIT POST HILL PRESS A triumphant, uplifting true justice story led by jury trial expert, Richard A. Sprague—the indomitable, nationally renowned prosecutor who engaged in the most intense manhunt investigation in police history. Coal Country Killing: A Culture, A Union, And The Murders That Changed It All, revolves around the cold-blooded 1969 assassination of United Mineworkers […]

Bookshelf

New Releases
Featured Books
Coming Soon
Award Winners

Business
History
Horror
Mysteries
Romance
Sci-Fi/Fantasy
Thrillers
True Crime
Biography
• Dances With Donkeys
• Secrets Of A Hollywood Private Eye
• Escape From Mariupol
• The Last Jewish Gangster, The Middle Years
• The Last Jewish Gangster, The Early Years
• The Last Jewish Gangster, The Final Years
True Crime
• I Will Ruin You
• The Siren Of San Quentin, Book One
• Becoming Clark Rockefeller
• Wrecking Crew (New Edition)
• Monsters On The Loose
• Murderers' Row, Volume Four
• Grim Paradise
• Bad Henry
• The Delphi Murders
• Stealing Manhattan
• Precious Few Clues
• Death By Talons
• Lou And Jonbenet
• Hidden Demons
• Love Me To Death
• By The Side Of The Road
• Going Under
• The Tuskegee Strangler
• The Decision To Kill
• All Along The Watchtower
• Ted Bundy
• Carmine And The 13Th Avenue Boys
• The Curse Of The Turtle
• Jane Doe 9
• Watch Me Die
• Mystery At The Blue Sea Cottage
• The Wheels Of Justice
• Terror Town, Usa
• Raging On
• The 'Peyton Place' Murder
• The World Encyclopedia Of Serial Killers Volume Four
• The World Encyclopedia Of Serial Killers
• First Degree Rage
• The Garden State Parkway Murders
• Playing Dead
• Mothers And Murderers
• Gabacho
• You Have A Very Soft Voice, Susan
• Wrecking Crew
• My Son, The Killer
• The Killing Game
• Shots In The Dark
• His Garden
• Burned
• The Case Of The Zodiac Killer
• The Beast I Loved
• Sidetracked
• Targeted
• Brooklyn's Most Wanted
• Betrayal In Blue
• Murderers Row
• Smooth Talker
• A Taste For Murder
• Man Overboard
• To Live And Lie In L.a.
• Lethal Doses
• The Moneymaker
• Coal Country Killing
• Killing The Messenger
Thriller
• The Dead Soul
• Gasping For Air
• Big Dogs
• The Shadowmaker
• A Nest Of Snakes
Mystery
• Deaf Row
• Murder At Mardi Gras
• Raptor's Ridge
• Headlock
• The Obituary
• The Deadline
Science Fiction
• Timberwolf
• Reawakened Worlds
• Dark Visions
• Hunter
Fantasy
• Dawn Of Legacy
• Destruction Of Justice
History
• Lucky Lady
• Above The Ground
• Fields Of Fortune
• Legion Rising
• The Korean Crisis
• Tempest Tost
• Saving Sandoval
• Killing Rasputin
Sci-Fi/Fantasy
• Rubicon

New Releases

Lawyer beind a desk and black and white image of her with convicted man

Author John Ferak Pens an Updated Epilogue for the WRECKING CREW 5th Anniversary, November 2023

"Ferak chronicles the long and sordid history of the Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department and the reason Sweaty's license was suspended. Framing Avery was just par for the course." -Kathleen Zellner Updated 5th Anniversary Edition Including … [More...]

book cover for THE DEAD SOUL by M. William Phelps

THE DEAD SOUL: A Thriller from New York Times Bestselling Author M. William Phelps

[THE DEAD SOUL] grabs you by the lapels and doesn't let go." -JOHN LUTZ, New York Times bestselling author From the desk of one of the most acclaimed and prolific true crime authors comes a mystery thriller certain to captivate his fans. M. … [More...]

Book cover for 'Monsters on the Loose' by Richard L. Carrico

MONSTERS ON THE LOOSE: The True Story of Three Unsolved Murders in Prohibition Era San Diego by Richard L. Carrico Tells the Tragic Story of Three Cold Case Murders

As an archaeologist, historian, and now murder investigator, the intellectual curiosity of Richard Carrico has no limits. Well researched and written, his new work, as with all good mysteries, takes us into unknown territories and keeps us reading … [More...]

front cover for MURDERERS' ROW volume four

WildBlue Press Presents MURDERERS’ ROW, Volume Four, a Collection of Three Best-selling True Crime Books from Burl Barer

New eBook Collection Out Now! This three-in-one volume features Edgar Award-winning author Burl Barer's works: MAN OVERBOARD, BETRAYAL IN BLUE, and A TASTE FOR MURDER. Barer, a media legend with a decades-spanning career, is a one-of-a-kind, … [More...]

Coming Soon

front cover for TIMBERWOLF by Tom Julian

Tom Julian’s TIMBERWOLF: Book One in the Spy-fi ‘Timberwolf’ Series is Coming Soon

Prepare for an adrenaline-fueled rollercoaster ride with TIMBERWOLF, the first installment in the gripping "spy-fi" series by Tom Julian, where thrilling espionage and futuristic encounters meet! "The storytelling in Timberwolf is some of the most … [More...]

Recent Posts

  • Author John Ferak Pens an Updated Epilogue for the WRECKING CREW 5th Anniversary, November 2023
  • Dan Lawton’s ABOVE THE GROUND Grabs a Spotlight Review by Kirkus Reviews!
  • THE DEAD SOUL: A Thriller from New York Times Bestselling Author M. William Phelps
  • A Serial Killer’s Fictional Counterpart
  • Jim Duke Shares a Thanksgiving Day Bloodshed Story
  • Catch the Latest Blog Post from Laurie Winslow Sargent, “The Tragedy of Henry Diddoh: a 1950s Frankenstein-ish story in Reawakened Worlds”
  • BECOMING CLARK ROCKEFELLER by Frank C. Girardot Jr. Spans Three Decades of Intrigue and Unravels Two High-profile Crimes

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

eZine SignupJoin our email list and be the first to get hot deals, new releases and...
* Author updates
* Free eBooks
* Free audio books
* Enlightening and entertaining posts
* Advance notice of book deals, special offers

Follow Us

Blog Tag Cloud

best true crime books Bogeyman Bradley Nickell Burl Barer Caitlin Rother Cold Case Crime Fiction Crime thriller Detective Detectives Facebook True Crime historical true crime history Investigation John Ferak Kevin Sullivan Las Vegas memoir Murder murder book murder mystery Mysteries Mystery mystery thriller Non-Fiction Serial Killer serial killer books Serial Killers Steve Jackson Suspense suspense thriller Ted Bundy Thriller Thriller Books True-crime True Crime truecrime True Crime Authors true crime book true crime books true crimes true crime stories True Murder WildBlue Press writing

Privacy Policy

As Seen On:

Our Authors Have Been Seen On...

Interested Authors Click Here
See Our Entire Catalog
SSL Secure Connection

Copyright © 2023 WildBlue Press. All rights reserved.
Website design by Denver Local SEO Marketing Company
Author Tiddy Smith Discusses Police Misconduct in Durham

Join our newsletter for awesome content, free offers and launch notifications!

By joining our list you will be entered into a contest for a free eBook, audio book or paperback of your choice! We select them regularly, so sign up NOW!

Loading